NOTE: These are just the lyrics that I hear. For example, some people hear “You’re counting all the sheep in the sky” as “You carry all the shame in disguise.” These lyrics are just as much as a possibility as what I hear. If you’re interested in staying updated in the search for this song, I reccomend going to the r/everyoneknowsthat subreddit. BACKSTORY: In 2001, a WatZatSong.com user with the username “Carl92” uploaded a snippet of a song with grainy audio that he called “Everyone Knows That.